Question.1129 - How does the Court find the 1st Amendment supports the web designer's position. What is the 303 Creative, LLC case's significance for business - any business?Also consider these questions in forming your essay. (Do not "list answers;" - Use these questions to help your thinking in creating a thoughtful response.) Have gender identity, race, ethnicity, and other protected classifications now ceased to be a "compelling governmental interest" by edict of the U.S. Supreme Court in this one case? Do you agree with the Court's decision for the web designer as to businesses serving the public? Is there a limit to saying "no" to a customer who differs from your personal belief? Does this case now give businesses a license to refuse anyone who has a different religious belief, or skin color, or gender identity, for example? Suppose, in the wedding context, it is not a LGBTQ+ couple's wedding but a Jewish wedding? Islamic? Pagan? Biracial?
Answer Below:
Considering xxx Creative xxx v xxxxxx case xxx of xxx stakeholders xxxxxxxx is xxxxx Smith xxx was x web xxxxxxxx who xxxxxxx a xxxxxxx against xxx Colorado xxxxx Rights xxxxxxxxxx and xxx Colorado xxxxxxxx General xx Smith xxx sought xx injunction xxxxxxxx to xx compelled xx create x website xxx same-sex xxxxxxxx which xxx against xxx religious xxxxxxx and xxx forcing xxx expression xxx speech xxxxx she xxxxx supported xx Smith's xxxxxxxxxx was xxxxxxx the xxxxxxxxxxx of xxx Colorado xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Act xxxx The xxxxxxxx made xx the xxxxxxx Court xxxxx the xxxx in xxxxx of xx Smith xx terms xx forcing xxx to xxxxxx a xxxxxxx expressing xxxxx inconsistent xxxx her xxxxxxxxx beliefs xxxxx to xxxxxxx the xxxxx Amendment xxxxx the xxxx Speech xxxxxx Camp xx terms xx business xxxx and xxxxxxxxxx this xxxxxx has xxxxxxxx the xxxxxxx for xxxxxxxxx working xxx places xx public xxxxxxxxxxxxx to xxxx services xx customers xx religious xxxxxxx The xxxx tends xx protect xxx First xxxxxxxxx since xx protects xx individual xxxx both xxx business xxxxxxx and xxxx being xxxxxxxxx to xxxxxxx views xxxx are xxxxxxx their xxxxxxxxx beliefs xxxxx in xxxx case xxx court xxxxxxxx to xxx creation xx a xxxxxxx as xxxxxxxxxx speech xxxx can xxxx be xxxx in xxx case xx Groff x Dejoy xxxxxxx undue xxxxxxxx got x reinterpretation xxxxx Title xxx religious xxxxxxxxxxxxxx but xxxx unanswered xxxxxxxxx pertaining xx the xxxxxxxxxxx of xxx new xxxxxxxx for xxxxxxxx owners xxxxxxxxx with xxxxxxx intent xxxxxxxx presentation xxxxx to xxxx up x wider xxxxx of xxxxxxxxxx questions xx terms xx employees xxxxxxx restraint xxxx providing x service xx customers xxxxx on xxxxx asserted xxxxxxxxx beliefs xxxx But xxx decision xx this xxxx also xxxxx to xxxxxxx a xxxxxxx between xxx government's xxxxxxxx in xxxxxxxxxxx discrimination xx places xx public xxxxxxx anti-discrimination xxxx should xxxx be xxxxxxxxx applied xx avoid xxxxxxxxxxxxxx protection xxxxxxxxxxxxx while xxxxxxxxxx the xxxx speech xxxxxx of xxxxxxxxxxx The xxxxxxxxxxxx of xxxxx like xxxxxx v xxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxx Cakeshop xxxx in xxx intersection xx anti-discrimination xxxx free xxxxxxxx of xxxxxxxx and xxxxxxx of xxxxxx in xxx context xx business xxxxxxxxxx Katzenbach x McClung xxxxxxxxxxx that xxxxxxx laws xxxx the xxxxx Rights xxx of xxx apply xx businesses xxxxxxxxxxx the xxxxxxxxxxxx interest xx preventing xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Katzenbach x McClung x S x d xxxxx The xxxxxxxx highlights xxxx compelling x business xxxxx to xxxxxxx services xxx an xxxxx that xx against xxxxx religious xxxxxxx since xx infringes xx freedom xx speech xxx religion xxx cases xxxxxxxx the xxxxxxxxxxxx of xxx businesses xxxxx their xxxxxx audiences xxx the xxxxx of xxxxx service xxx be xxxxxxxx on xxx basis xx religious xxxxxxx while xxxxxxxx attention xx sustaining x balance xxxxxxx the xxxxxx of xxxxxxxxxxx to xx free xxxx discrimination xxx the xxxxxx of xxxxxxxxxx owners xx practice xxxxx religion xxxxx implies xxxxx streamlining xx business xxxxxxxxx Firstly xxxxxxxx Belief xx Business xxxxxxxx The xxxxx question xxx limit xx saying xx based xx personal xxxxxxx when xxxxxxxxx a xxxxxxx to xxx public xxxxx exploring xxxxxxxx circumstances xxx the xxxxx of xxxxxxxxxx to xxxxxx their xxxxxxx without xxxxxxxxx anti-discrimination xxxx Secondly xxxxxxxxxx a xxxxxxx in xxxxxx since xxxxxx have xxx responsibility xx legally xxxxxxx all xxx stakeholder's xxxxxx on xxx basis xx the xxxxxx of xxxxxxx in xxxxx of xxxxxxxx owner xxxxxx to xxxxxx service xxxxxx on xxxxxxxxxxx to xxxxxxx a xxxxxxx and xxx existence xx alternative xxxxxxx providers xxxxxxx to xxxxxx Based xx Religion xxxx Color xx Gender xxxxxxxx Narrow xx Broad xxxxxxxxxxxxxx The xxxxx don't xxxxxxxxxxx give xxxxxxxxxx a xxxxx license xx refuse xxxxxx based xx religion xxxx color xx gender xxxxxxxx However xxxxxx may xxxxxxxx the xxxxxxxx facts xx each xxxx and xxxxxxx the xxxxxxx is x reasonable xxxxxxxxxxxxx of xxx business xxxxxxx beliefs xx an xxxxxxxxxxx act xx discrimination xxxxxxxxxx v xxxxxxx U x n x Ashar xxxxxxx Context xxx context xx a xxxxxxx whether xxxxx Jewish xxxxxxx Pagan xx biracial xxxx complexity xxxxxxx courts xxx examine xxx reasons xxxxxx refusals xx such xxxxxxxx and xxxxxxx they xxx genuinely xxxxxx in xxxxxxxxx beliefs xx amount xx discriminatory xxxxxxxxx Katzenbach x McClung x S x d xxxxx References xxxxx L x July xxxxxxx Court xxxxx send xxxxx messages xxxxx LGBTQ xxxxxx Edge xxxxx apuedge xxx supreme-court-cases-send-mixed-messages-about-lgbtq-rights x Camp x November xxxxxxxxx beware xxx potential xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx impacts xx Creative xxx v xxxxxx Foley xxx Lardner xxx https xxx foley xxx insights xxxxxxxxxxxx employment-related-impacts- xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Oyez x d xxxxxxxxxx v xxxxxxx U x Katzenbach x McClung xxxxx www xxxx org xxxxx Prs xxxxxxxxx Impact xx Employee xxxxxx The xxxx has xxxxxxxxx implications xx the xxxxxxxxxx context xxxxxxxxx the xxxxxxx of xxxxxxxxx working xxx places xx public xxxxxxxxxxxxx to xxxx services xx customers xxxxx on xxxxxxxxx grounds xxxxxxxxx may xxxxxx to xxxxxxx projects xx workplace xxxxxxxx on xxxxxxxxx or xxxxx Amendment xxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxx might xxxx challenges xx accommodating xxxx objections xxxxxxxxx Threat xx Political xxxxxxxxxxx Claims xxx ruling xxx increase xxx threat xx political xxxxxxxxxxx claims xxxxxxxxxxxx an xxxxxxxxxx ability xx discipline xxxxxxxxx for xxxxxxx services xx certain xxxxxxxxx Employees xxxxx claim xxxx threats xx discharge xxx refusing xx work xx projects xxxxx on x First xxxxxxxxx objection xxx motivated xx animus xxxxxx their xxxxxxxxx beliefs xxxxxxxxxx Questions xx Employment xxxxxxx The xxxx leaves xxxx questions xx the xxxxxxxxxx context xxxx as xxx line xxxxxxx expressive xxxxxxxx that xxxxxxxxxx speech xxx other xxxxxxxx that xx not xxx outcome xxx depend xx factors xxxx whether xxx content xx customized xxx each xxxxxx or xx virtually xxx same xxx everyone xxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxx Compelling xxxxxxxxxxxx Interest xxx case xxxxxx questions xxxxx whether xxxxxxxxx classifications xxxx gender xxxxxxxx race xxx ethnicity xxxx ceased xx be x compelling xxxxxxxxxxxx interest xx this xxxxxxx It xxxxxxxxxx the xxxxxxx between xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx laws xxx free xxxxxx rights xxxxxxxx Beliefs xx Customer xxxxxxx The xxxxxxxx prompts xxxxxxxxxxxxx of xxx limits xx saying xx to x customer xxxxx on xxxxxxxx beliefs xx highlights xxx challenge xx balancing xx individual's xxxxx to xxxxxx service xxxx the xxxxxxxx interest xx preventing xxxxxxxxxxxxxx License xx Refuse xxxxxxx There xx a xxxxxxx about xxxxxxx this xxxx gives xxxxxxxxxx a xxxxxxx to xxxxxx anyone xxxx different xxxxxxxxx beliefs xxxx color xx gender xxxxxxxx The xxxxx of xxx decision's xxxxxxxxxxx to xxxxxxx scenarios xxxx as xxxxxxxx of xxxxxxxxx cultural xx religious xxxxxxxxxxx remains xxxxxxx In xxxxxxxxxx the xxxxxxxx LLC xxxx has xxxxxxxxxxx implications xxx the xxxxxxxxxxxx of xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx laws xxxx speech xxxxxx and xxxxxxxx practices xx reinforces xxx protection xx First xxxxxxxxx rights xx the xxxxxxx of xxxxxx accommodations xxx may xxxxxxxxx how xxxxxxxxxx navigate xxx tension xxxxxxx serving xxx public xxx respecting xxxxxxxxxx beliefsMore Articles From Strategic Management
.ico)
.ico)
.ico)
.ico)
